Kimmich's Bundesliga XI: A Bayern Fan's Head-Scratching Selection
Share
The Bold (and Controversial) Choice
Bayern Munich fans, brace yourselves. Midfielder Joshua Kimmich recently unveiled his “Ultimate Bundesliga XI,” and the reaction has been… mixed, to say the least. In a collaboration with 433 and the Bundesliga, Kimmich selected a team that has left many Bavarian faithful scratching their heads. Was it a nostalgic trip down memory lane, or a genuine misjudgment of Bundesliga legends?
The Starting XI: A Breakdown
Let's dissect Kimmich's choices, team by team. Here's the lineup that sparked the debate:
- Goalkeeper: Manuel Neuer
- Defense: Philipp Lahm, Dayot Upamecano, Franz Beckenbauer, David Alaba
- Midfield: Toni Kroos, Xabi Alonso, Florian Wirtz
- Attack: Kingsley Coman, Jamal Musiala, Franck Ribéry
Goalkeeping Genius
Kimmich’s selection of Manuel Neuer is undeniable. The veteran goalkeeper is widely considered one of the greatest of all time, and his inclusion is a no-brainer for any Bundesliga XI. Learn more about Neuer's impact on the game.
Defensive Dilemmas
The defensive line presents a more complex picture. Philipp Lahm, the undisputed GOAT, earns his spot. David Alaba, a familiar face from Kimmich’s Bayern days, also makes the cut. However, the inclusion of Dayot Upamecano over established Bundesliga stalwarts like Mats Hummels raises eyebrows. While Upamecano is a valuable asset for Bayern, his legacy doesn't quite match the legends he's alongside. Franz Beckenbauer, of course, is an automatic selection – a true icon of the game.
Midfield Mayhem
The midfield is where Kimmich’s XI truly falters. Toni Kroos, a proven Bundesliga performer, and Xabi Alonso are solid choices. However, the inclusion of Florian Wirtz, a relatively young player with only a couple of standout seasons, feels premature for an “Ultimate” XI. Consider the wealth of midfield talent Kimmich has played with – Lothar Matthäus, Bastian Schweinsteiger, Thiago Alcântara, and even Thomas Müller, who could easily slot into a midfield role, are all arguably more deserving. Explore the betting odds on future Bundesliga stars.
Attacking Absurdities
Franck Ribéry’s inclusion is understandable, a testament to his brilliance during his time at Bayern. Kingsley Coman is a decent pick, but placing Jamal Musiala as a striker, ahead of legends like Gerd Müller, Robert Lewandowski, and even current teammate Harry Kane, is simply baffling. To omit Lewandowski, a Bundesliga record-breaker, is a significant oversight. The lack of a traditional striker is a glaring weakness in Kimmich’s selection.
Why the Choices Don't Quite Add Up
It appears Kimmich’s selections were heavily influenced by familiarity and personal connections rather than a comprehensive assessment of Bundesliga history. While personal preference is valid, an “Ultimate XI” should prioritize legacy and overall impact on the league.
Your Turn: Build Your Own Ultimate XI!
Do you think you can assemble a better Bundesliga XI than Joshua Kimmich? Share your dream team in the comments below! We want to see your choices and hear your reasoning. Check out our analysis of Bundesliga player performance.
